The original version of The Reaper by Blue Öyster Cult is not played in this episode.  They used a cover version by Caesars.

It's The Most Wonderful Time Of The Year

The Fisher's gather around the kitchen table to discuss Christmas plans.

Andy Williams

Let It Snow

Claire & Toby walk around the mall and talk about their strange family Christmas experiences.

The Mighty Turbans

Jingle Bells

Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart

Concerto for Flute & Orchestra in D Major

Brenda & a male shopper start a surreptitious sexual encounter before being interrupted by the sales lady.

Joel Evans

What Child Is This

At Margaret's Christmas party, Brenda is shocked to find her brother Billy, who has just gotten out of the hospital.

Bobby Timmons

Deck The Halls

Jessie's favorite song is played at his funeral.

Steppenwolf

Born To Be Wild

Later at Margaret's Christmas party, Brenda tells Billy that she and Nate are engaged.

Scott Hamilton

Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas

David recalls seeing his dad for the last time, talking next to the Christmas tree one year ago.

Dodie Stevens

Merry, Merry Christmas Baby

Brenda arrives at the Fisher's for Christmas dinner while biker funeral is taking place.

The Outlaws

Green Grass & High Tides

The Allman Brothers Band

Midnight Rider

After dinner Claire tells Brenda she has been in touch with Billy while he was in the hospital.

Lynyrd Skynyrd

Free Bird

Tobey criticizes Claire's negative attitude; Nate has a warm conversation with the deceased's wife about her love for Jessie, motorcycles, and living life to the fullest.

Sweet Home Alabama

Blue Öyster Cult

(Don't Fear) The Reaper

Bach

Christmas Oratorio (Sinfonia in G)

Divertimento in D Major for Strings

Nate watches bikers hold up cigarette lighters and raise their beers for their fallen comrade; repeated later when Nate is given keys to Jessie's motorcycle and zooms off.